Who would win in an Indie Girl-off, Joanna Newsom or Cat Power?

Joanna Newsom:

• Pros:
  
  • That voice
  • Cites Nabokov as a primary lyrical influence
  • Plays harp, harpsichord
  • Bangs
• Cons:
  • That voice
  • Large vocabulary is daunting
  • Ys is more referred than listened to

Cat Power:

• Pros:
  • That voice
  • Indie gorgeous
  • Mentally unstable/bad live performer
  • Named after trucker hats when trucker hats were cool
• Cons:
  • No longer mentally unstable?
  • Sold out to Channel, Debeers, Cingular, et al.
  • Recent albums are too happy

Who do you have?