Done. Is there a more fun-masturbatory thing than the Pitchfork People’s List? No.
I settled on using one album per artist because I had way too many forgotten/missed albums (and come on I can’t have 5% Kanye West albums and 6% Radiohead albums).
The Interpol-Broken Social Scene-Arcade Fire-Wilco block is one part of my life; the National-Sleater-Kinney-Hold Steady block is another. I generally broke my list down into genre blocks, life blocks, or year blocks, which made it easier and gave numbers, like, 21-100 a bit more meaning. Anyway, super fun thing to do. You should do it.