ke pitchfork | B Michael Tumblr
Done. Is there a more fun-masturbatory thing than the Pitchfork People’s List? No.

I settled on using one album per artist because I had way too many forgotten/missed albums (and come on I can’t have 5% Kanye West albums and 6% Radiohead albums).

The Interpol-Broken Social Scene-Arcade Fire-Wilco block is one part of my life; the National-Sleater-Kinney-Hold Steady block is another. I generally broke my list down into genre blocks, life blocks, or year blocks, which made it easier and gave numbers, like, 21-100 a bit more meaning. Anyway, super fun thing to do. You should do it.

Done. Is there a more fun-masturbatory thing than the Pitchfork People’s List? No.

I settled on using one album per artist because I had way too many forgotten/missed albums (and come on I can’t have 5% Kanye West albums and 6% Radiohead albums).

The Interpol-Broken Social Scene-Arcade Fire-Wilco block is one part of my life; the National-Sleater-Kinney-Hold Steady block is another. I generally broke my list down into genre blocks, life blocks, or year blocks, which made it easier and gave numbers, like, 21-100 a bit more meaning. Anyway, super fun thing to do. You should do it.

katherinestasaph:

Alpine, “Tough Skin”

I’m at the stage of adoration with the Catcall record (it was on Fader! and then Pitchfork! people might actually be listening to this outside Australia soon!) where I’m actively looking up other groups on their label. (OK, the SoundCloud the record’s streaming on that has a record label’s name, which I’d say is evidence enough.) This track’s another sleek, synthpop track, the sort that’s starting to exceed the music world’s carrying capacity, but it’s warmer, dreamier; think a more acoustic Little Dragon, perhaps, or (if you’ve humored my incessant talking about the record) a faster-paced Sophie Zeyl. I tend to prefer spikier music anyway — it’s why I’m hesitant to listen to the new Beach House, even though people who’ve actually heard the record might find that really silly to read — and when it’s gorgeous too, that’s even better.

I like this song and EP a lot! And also the Catcall album. This is all great!

And now. I’m sorry - but I am going to derail this lovely song and above thought a little bit: I enjoy Ian Cohen’s reviews and I enjoy (or, well, seem to get a pleasant frisson from) Andrew “Falco” Falkous. But angry dudes arguing about who’s angrier - especially when one of you is a noted maker of angry music and the other is a noted maker of angry (or “panning-the-fuck-out-of”) music reviews is somehow a lot less interesting than I thought it would have been. That being said… it sounds like more of a messaging-attention problem than a review problem: If someone is judging an entire album based on two quoted-quoted lines, then maybe you don’t want them as a fan. (J/k - you do because of the $$$.)

It could be the weather, but I sort of like this Beach House-Grimes-2:54-Catcall-Alpine chill thing going on right now.

You don’t need me to tell you this, but “Passin’” is an absolute masterpiece, the too-smart-by-half class clowns ruminating on their romantic insufficiencies. It’s the group’s biggest hit, and the primary reason to call Bizarre “one of the most joyously heartbreaking albums ever,” as Ernest Hardy did. Powered by Fatlip’s impassioned howl on the chorus (which J-Swift claims in the box-set liners was a playful Jim Morrison impression arising from The Doors playing at the crib), “Passin’” is half-rapped, half-sung soul music made by a group of kids remarkably unafraid of seeming uncool or wussy. Fatlip emerges as the star, singing the hook and delivering one of rap’s all-time greatest climax verses. It opens with the lovely bit of lyrical hopscotch “now there she goes again, the dopest Ethiopian,” and concludes with two bars that firmly situate the song in a litany of pop sentiment, nodding toward Rodgers & Hart, and sending two shouts to Elvis at his most lovelorn. Buffeted by high rotation on “Yo! MTV Raps” and BET’s “Rap City”, the song’s arty black and white video (which Ross recalls being beat out by Onyx’s “Slam” as MTV’s one regular-rotation rap clip) made the Pharcyde a hit with rap fans and Buzz Bin acolytes alike. “If we got that MTV slot,” Ross remembers, “I can only imagine how big that song would have gotten.

Eric Harvey’s on a historiographic music writing tear! Thoroughly enjoyed reading this review, and learned even more.

To this point, they’ve answered the question of “are they really serious?” in the affirmative or made it a moot point— whether you just liked the Big Punisher quotes, casually accepted being called a white demon for the greater good, or both, their work could be enjoyed on any number of levels. But Relax feels like it’s hovering over a more pernicious escape clause— “you don’t get it.” Interpreted through telling lyrics like “when you see me on the streets, don’t bother me,” “I don’t know why people think we give a fuck so often,” or, as the closing argument in “Celebration” goes, “you could ask what it is, but I still wouldn’t tell you,” the title of Relax feels more like a statement of aggression, Das Racist shifting the blame to the listener for their own lack of commitment.

Ian Cohen made some good points regarding DR’s rapping, and the fact that the highest highs of their mixtapes are higher than the highs on Relax. On the other hand, I’ve never felt like I was “being called a white demon for the greater good” when I was listening to the music, or felt threatened by their anti-white sentiments, like the “No qualms with cockblocking white dudes from Boston” line that comes before the above “I don’t now why people think we give a fuck so often” line. This is an interesting review… I think, for where it’s coming from, the score makes sense.